How does Shen, Leader of the Kinkou Order work when I hold with Trevor and summon Sprite after holding, will I score 2 points and then get the sprites, and is it the same if the sprite dies?

Question

Accepted Answer

You only get the score from each triggered instance of Shen, Leader of the Kinkou Order once when that triggered ability resolves. Whether a Sprite token is summoned after you Hold does not retroactively create an extra score for that Hold trigger. If the Sprite was present at the moment the Hold event occurred and the Hold trigger saw exactly one other unit, the trigger will be created and will score when it resolves. If the Sprite is created after the Hold trigger is already created, it does not cause that same trigger to score again. A Sprite dying later (including being killed at the start of the Beginning Phase) does not retroactively change a triggered ability that already resolved.

When you Hold with Shen, Leader of the Kinkou Order and exactly one other unit (e.g. Trevor) is present at that moment, the Shen's 'When I hold, if there is exactly one other unit you control here, you score 1 point.' triggered ability will be placed on the chain and, when it resolves, will score 1 point. Summoning a Sprite after the Hold does not make that same Hold trigger score again. If you had multiple independent triggers (for example, multiple copies of Shen, Leader of the Kinkou Order each triggered separately), each qualifying trigger can score when its own trigger resolves. A Sprite dying later (including the token being killed at the start of a Beginning Phase per its card text) does not undo or grant additional scores for a Hold trigger that already occurred.

You perform the Hold action with Shen, Leader of the Kinkou Order at a battlefield that also has exactly one other unit you control (for example Trevor). The 'When I hold, if there is exactly one other unit you control here, you score 1 point.' triggered ability becomes Pending and is added to the Chain in the appropriate order per triggered-ability placement rules [459.2.d.3]. That trigger sits on the Chain as a new item. When that item becomes the newest on the Chain and resolves, its effect executes and you score 1 point then, per the ability text and the chain resolution rules [340.1]. If you summon a Sprite token after the Hold event (i.e., after the trigger has already been created and placed on the Chain), that later change to board state does not retroactively create a second copy of the original Hold trigger, nor does it retroactively alter whether the already-created trigger will resolve to score. The original trigger was created based on the board state at the moment the Hold occurred [459.2.d.3] (assumption described above). If the Sprite token is killed later (for example tokens created by Lillia - Fae Fawn or Sprite Queen are explicitly killed at the start of their controller's next Beginning Phase before scoring), that death does not retroactively affect a Hold trigger that already resolved earlier. Death and cleanup timing for tokens happens independently later in the turn/Beginning Phase as instructed by their card text and the Cleanup/Death rules [808.1.d.2]. If you had multiple separate triggers (for instance multiple distinct copies of Shen, Leader of the Kinkou Order that each 'held' and each saw exactly one other unit at their own Hold moment), each qualifying trigger would be added and could each resolve to score independently.

If the Sprite was already present at the battlefield at the exact time you Hold, then it counts as the 'other unit' for Shen, Leader of the Kinkou Order and the Hold-trigger would be created because the condition is met at trigger-creation time. If the 'if' condition were intended to be rechecked only on resolution (the rulebook excerpt does not explicitly state which timing model applies), the result could differ if board state changes before the trigger resolves. Because that detail is not present in the provided Core Rules excerpt, I used the defensible convention that the condition is checked when the trigger is created and the trigger is added to the chain [459.2.d.3] (see Assumptions). Multiple Shens: If you somehow have two copies of Shen, Leader of the Kinkou Order and both Hold and each sees exactly one other unit at their respective Hold times, both will create triggers and each can score 1 point when each trigger resolves. If a token is created and then immediately removed before the Hold event occurs, it never counted at the Hold moment and won't cause the Hold trigger to be created.

How the timing works in this situation depends on when the 'When I hold...' triggered ability is created and what board state is seen at that exact moment. Triggered abilities created by game events are placed on the Chain as Pending Items in the appropriate order [459.2.d.3]. The most defensible interpretation from the provided rules and standard triggered-ability handling is that the 'if there is exactly one other unit you control here' is evaluated when the Hold event creates the trigger, so the trigger only becomes Pending if that condition is true at the time of the Hold (Assumptions). Once the trigger is on the Chain, the newest item resolves in full when it reaches resolution [340.1], and its effect (scoring 1 point) happens then. Therefore: if you Hold with Shen, Leader of the Kinkou Order and exactly one other unit (like Trevor) is present at that moment, the Shen will create a trigger and you will score 1 point when that trigger resolves. Summoning a Sprite after the Hold does not retroactively create an additional score from that same Hold trigger, because the original trigger was created based on the board state at the time of the Hold and will resolve accordingly [459.2.d.3] [340.1]. Similarly, if the Sprite dies later (for example, tokens created by Lillia - Fae Fawn or Sprite Queen are explicitly killed at the start of their controller's next Beginning Phase before scoring per their card text), that later death does not retroactively undo or create scores for an already-resolved Hold trigger. If you want multiple scores, you need multiple separate qualifying triggers — for example multiple copies of Shen, Leader of the Kinkou Order each holding while their condition is met — each trigger can then score when it resolves. Relevant rules: triggered-ability placement at chain creation [459.2.d.3], the fact that trigger items resolve as the newest item on the Chain [340.1], and Deathknell/trigger creation being placed on the Chain before movement in kill contexts [808.1.d.2].